UK cities
45+
Direct coverage
Comparison guide
Accident management vs claims management company: what's the difference in the UK?
A plain-English UK comparison of two terms drivers mix up - the property-damage accident management that needs no FCA authorisation, and the FCA-regulated claims management company that pursues injury and financial claims for a fee.
- 24/7 UK dispatch
- £0 upfront cost
- Independent engineer
- Like-for-like replacement
24/7
UK response
Recovery dispatch and live claim handlers, 365 days a year.
Response
<60m
First contact SLA
Cost
£0
Upfront to driver
What is the difference between accident management and a claims management company in the UK?
Accident management is the property-damage logistics after a non-fault crash - recovery, storage, independent engineer inspection, repair coordination, a like-for-like replacement vehicle and direct dialogue with the at-fault driver's insurer. It sits outside the FCA's claims-management regulated perimeter and needs no FCA authorisation, and on a non-fault claim it is provided at no upfront cost because the at-fault insurer pays. A claims management company (CMC) is an FCA-regulated firm authorised under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 to pursue personal-injury, financial or other regulated claims for a fee under the FCA's CMCOB sourcebook. CityGrip does the accident management itself and refers any injury or regulated claim, with your explicit consent, to an authorised partner.
At a glance
The two services, side by side
UK drivers, brokers and even some insurers use these two terms loosely, but they describe different activities on different sides of the FCA's regulated perimeter. Here is the comparison most people actually need after a non-fault collision.
| Feature | Accident management | Claims management company (CMC) |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | Property-damage logistics: recovery, storage, engineer inspection, repairs, replacement vehicle, third-party insurer dialogue | Pursuing regulated claims: personal injury, financial-product mis-selling, housing disrepair and other specified claim types |
| FCA authorisation | Not required - sits outside the claims-management regulated perimeter | Required - authorised and supervised by the FCA under FSMA 2000 |
| Rulebook | General consumer law, UK GDPR, the law of damages and mitigation | FCA Claims Management: Conduct of Business sourcebook (CMCOB) |
| Who pays | The at-fault driver's insurer pays the property-damage costs | You pay - usually a percentage of the compensation recovered |
| Cost to a non-fault driver | No upfront cost where liability is admitted | A success fee, disclosed up front and capped by the FCA for certain claims |
| Legal advice | None given - this is logistics, not legal representation | May advise on and represent the regulated claim within its permissions |
| Typical trigger | Your car is damaged or off the road after a non-fault crash | You have been injured, or have a financial / regulated claim to pursue |
| How CityGrip fits | Provided directly, in-house, end to end | Referred to an authorised CMC or SRA solicitor with your explicit consent |
Sources: Financial Services and Markets Act 2000; Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2018; the FCA Claims Management: Conduct of Business sourcebook (CMCOB); UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018. General guidance, not legal advice.
What accident management actually is
Accident management is the practical, logistical side of putting a non-fault driver back on the road after a collision. When another driver hits you, a long list of physical tasks has to happen quickly: the damaged vehicle may need recovering from the scene, it has to be stored somewhere secure while liability is sorted out, an independent engineer should inspect it to decide repair-versus-write-off and pre-accident value, the repair has to be booked into a competent body shop, you usually need a like-for-like replacement vehicle so your life keeps moving, and somebody has to write to the at-fault driver's insurer to get all of that paid for. That bundle of work is accident management.
Crucially, none of it is a 'claim' in the regulated sense. It is the management of property damage and the day-to-day inconvenience that flows from a crash. The legal backbone is the ordinary law of damages: the at-fault party must put you back, so far as money can, into the position you were in before the accident (restitutio in integrum), and you in turn must act reasonably to keep those costs proportionate (the duty to mitigate). An accident-management business coordinates the recovery operators, storage compounds, engineers, repairers and replacement-vehicle providers, and presents the resulting costs to the third-party insurer.
Because the at-fault insurer is the paying party on a clear non-fault claim, genuine accident management is provided to you at no upfront cost. You do not pay your own policy excess, you do not take a fault marker on your renewal, and you keep the use of a vehicle throughout. That is the model CityGrip runs: recovery, secure storage, independent engineer inspection, repair coordination, like-for-like replacement vehicle and direct correspondence with the at-fault driver's insurer - all in-house.
What a claims management company actually is
A claims management company, or CMC, is something quite specific in UK law. It is a business that carries on 'regulated claims management activity' for a fee - seeking out potential claims, referring them, advising on them, investigating them, or representing the claimant. The classic examples are personal-injury claims after an accident, mis-sold financial products (the PPI era was the high-water mark), packaged bank accounts, housing disrepair and certain specified benefit and employment claims. The defining feature is that a CMC is pursuing a legal or financial claim on your behalf and charging you for the result.
Since 1 April 2019, CMCs in England, Wales and Scotland have been authorised and supervised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Before that, claims management regulation sat with the Claims Management Regulator at the Ministry of Justice; the Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2018 moved it to the FCA. An authorised CMC must follow the FCA's dedicated rulebook, the Claims Management: Conduct of Business sourcebook (CMCOB). That sourcebook governs how they may market, what they must tell you before you sign, how they handle your money and how they treat vulnerable customers.
A CMC is not the same as a solicitor. A solicitor is regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) and can conduct litigation and give reserved legal advice; a CMC operates within narrower permissions and frequently passes the actual litigation to a panel law firm. For a road-accident injury claim, you might be dealt with by a CMC, by an SRA-regulated solicitor, or by a solicitor to whom a CMC has referred you. What matters for this comparison is that all of them sit inside a regulated claims perimeter that property-damage accident management does not.
03
03
Section 3 of the walkthrough.
The FCA regulated perimeter: the line that separates the two
The whole distinction turns on a single concept: the regulated perimeter. The Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 makes it an offence to carry on a 'regulated activity' by way of business in the UK without authorisation. Claims management was brought inside that perimeter by the Financial Guidance and Claims Act 2018 and the secondary legislation that defines the regulated claims-management activities. If what you do falls inside the definition, you must be FCA-authorised; if it falls outside, you must not pretend to be, and you do not need authorisation.
Regulated claims-management activity is, broadly, seeking out, referrals and identification of claims or potential claims, plus advice, investigation or representation in relation to a personal-injury claim, a financial-services or financial-product claim, a housing-disrepair claim, a specified benefit claim, a criminal-injuries claim or an employment-related claim. Notice what these have in common: they are all about pursuing a legal or financial claim for compensation. That is the regulated heartland.
Arranging the recovery of a crashed car, storing it, commissioning an engineer's report, booking the repair and providing a replacement vehicle while corresponding with the third-party insurer about those property-damage costs is not within that list. It is the handling of physical damage and consequential motoring losses, not the pursuit of a regulated compensation claim. That is why a legitimate accident-management business can do this work without FCA claims-management authorisation - and why the honest version of the business is careful never to stray into giving injury or financial-claims advice it is not authorised to give.
There is an important nuance on credit hire. Supplying a like-for-like replacement vehicle on credit can engage the Consumer Credit Act 1974 if the agreement is a regulated credit agreement, in which case consumer-credit protections (and, where relevant, the appropriate permissions) apply to that agreement. That is a different regime from claims-management regulation, but it is a reminder that 'outside the FCA claims-management perimeter' does not mean 'outside all regulation'.
The fee models are fundamentally different
Because the two services sit on different sides of the perimeter, they are paid for in completely different ways, and conflating them is where drivers get caught out. Genuine accident management on a non-fault claim costs you nothing upfront. The recovery invoice, the storage charges, the engineer's fee, the repair bill and the replacement-vehicle charges are all heads of loss recovered from the at-fault driver's insurer under the law of damages. If liability is admitted, you are not out of pocket, and there is no success fee skimmed from a compensation pot, because property damage is paid in full rather than as a negotiated lump sum.
A CMC's fee, by contrast, is a charge to you. It is almost always a percentage of the compensation the CMC recovers on your behalf - a contingency or 'success' fee. Under CMCOB the CMC must give you a clear pre-contract information summary, set out the fee, illustrate what you would actually receive after the fee, and give you a 14-day cancellation right. For certain claim types the FCA has imposed fee caps, so the percentage a CMC may charge is limited by band. None of this is hidden, but it is a deduction from your money, which is the opposite of the property-damage model.
There is a third model worth naming so you can tell them apart: the solicitor's no-win-no-fee conditional fee agreement (CFA). On an injury claim run by an SRA solicitor, a success fee may be deducted from your damages, capped by law for personal-injury work. That CFA success fee is a legal-services charge, again separate from accident management. The simple test is this: if someone is taking a cut of a compensation settlement, you are in claims-management or legal-services territory; if your vehicle costs are being recovered in full from the other side's insurer, you are in accident-management territory.
Who needs which - and when both apply
For most non-fault drivers the honest answer is: you need accident management, and you may additionally need a regulated injury claim. These are not competing choices; they are two workstreams that often run in parallel. If your only loss is to the car - it is damaged, off the road, needs recovering, storing, inspecting, repairing and replacing while that happens - accident management covers all of it and you do not need a CMC at all. The vehicle side of the great majority of non-fault claims never touches the regulated perimeter.
You move into CMC or solicitor territory the moment there is a personal-injury element, or another regulated claim, that someone is going to pursue for compensation. A whiplash or soft-tissue injury, a more serious injury, a passenger's injury, or a financial loss that needs a regulated claim - these are the triggers. At that point you want an FCA-authorised CMC or, more usually for road-accident injuries, an SRA-regulated solicitor, often via the Official Injury Claim portal for lower-value whiplash claims under the Civil Liability Act 2018.
The practical sequence we use is straightforward. We open and run the accident-management file immediately - recovery, storage, engineer, repair, replacement vehicle, insurer correspondence - because that is time-critical and is ours to do. If you have been injured, we explain that the injury claim is a separate, regulated matter we cannot run ourselves, and we offer to refer it to an authorised partner. You decide whether to accept that referral. The vehicle side proceeds either way; it is never held hostage to the injury decision.
06
How the injury referral works - and why consent is the whole point
Because CityGrip is an accident-management business and not an FCA-authorised CMC or an SRA-regulated law firm, it does not advise on or run personal-injury claims in-house. Where you are injured, the injury element is referred to an authorised partner who holds the right permissions. That referral is governed by data-protection law, and the safeguard at its centre is your consent.
- A separate purpose needs a lawful basis. Passing your details to an injury firm is a distinct processing purpose, so it needs its own legal ground. CityGrip relies on your consent under UK GDPR Article 7 and the Data Protection Act 2018 - not on a buried tick-box or an assumption.
- Freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous. That is the Article 7 standard. You are told who the partner is, exactly what is shared and why, and you opt in deliberately. Silence or pre-ticked boxes do not count.
- You can withdraw at any time. Consent is not a one-way door. You can change your mind, and withdrawing it must be as easy as giving it.
- No obligation, no dependency. You never have to accept a referral, you are free to instruct any solicitor you choose, and the accident-management service continues regardless.
This is also why you should be wary of any firm that treats an injury referral as automatic, or that cannot tell you whether it is the regulated party or merely the introducer. The cleaner the line between the property-damage work and the regulated injury work, the better protected you are. See how our consent-based injury referral works.
07
How to tell which one you are actually dealing with
Marketing blurs the labels, so judge a firm by what it does, not what it calls itself. A few practical tests cut through it:
- Follow the money. Is your vehicle cost being recovered in full from the at-fault insurer (accident management), or is someone taking a percentage of a compensation settlement (claims management or legal services)?
- Ask about authorisation. A firm running injury or financial claims for a fee should be FCA-authorised (or an SRA-regulated solicitor). A pure accident-management business should be candid that it is not within the FCA claims-management perimeter and refers regulated work out.
- Watch for the consent moment. Before any injury referral, you should be asked to opt in, told who the partner is, and told you can decline. No consent step is a red flag.
- Separate the workstreams. A good operator keeps the property-damage file and the injury file distinct, so your replacement vehicle and repair never depend on whether you pursue an injury claim.
CityGrip is deliberately on the accident-management side of that line. We recover, store, inspect, repair and replace, and we deal with the at-fault insurer on the vehicle - then, only with your consent, we introduce any injury claim to an authorised partner. For the related money questions, see who pays for what after a non-fault accident and our guide to how no-win-no-fee actually works.
0608Key takeaway
Where CityGrip sits, and why that protects you
CityGrip Accident Claims is a UK accident-management business. The recovery, secure storage, independent engineer inspection, repair coordination, like-for-like replacement vehicle and third-party-insurer correspondence are all done in-house, at no upfront cost to a non-fault driver, because those activities sit outside the FCA's claims-management regulated perimeter and are paid by the at-fault insurer. That is the core service, and it is the part you almost always need.
What CityGrip does not do is hold itself out as an FCA-authorised CMC or an SRA-regulated solicitor. It does not give legal advice and it does not run personal-injury or other regulated claims itself. Where you are injured, or have another regulated claim, that work is referred - only with your explicit, recorded consent under UK GDPR Article 7 - to authorised CMCs or SRA-regulated panel solicitors who hold the relevant permissions. Drawing that line clearly is not a limitation; it is a consumer protection. It means the regulated work is done by regulated people, the unregulated logistics are done quickly and at no cost to you, and you stay in control of every referral.
Get the vehicle side handled today
We manage the accident itself - recovery, storage, engineer inspection, repairs and a like-for-like replacement vehicle - and deal with the at-fault insurer directly. If you have been injured, we refer the injury claim to an authorised partner, only with your consent.
UK general guidance only - not legal advice. CityGrip Accident Claims is an accident-management business; recovery, storage, repair coordination, engineer inspection, replacement vehicle and third-party-insurer correspondence sit outside the FCA's claims-management regulated perimeter and do not require FCA authorisation. Personal-injury and other regulated claims are referred, only with your explicit consent, to FCA-authorised claims management companies or SRA-regulated solicitors who hold the relevant permissions. Specific rules and fee caps can change; the position at the date of any individual matter will govern its handling. For the related routes see personal injury claims after a car accident or contact our team.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between accident management and a claims management company?
- Accident management is the property-damage logistics after a non-fault crash - recovery, secure storage, independent engineer inspection, repair coordination, a like-for-like replacement vehicle and direct correspondence with the at-fault driver's insurer. These activities sit outside the FCA's claims-management regulated perimeter and need no FCA authorisation. A claims management company (CMC) is an FCA-regulated firm authorised under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 to carry out regulated claims-management activity - typically seeking out, advising on or pursuing personal-injury, financial-product or other regulated claims for a fee under the FCA's CMCOB sourcebook.
- Is accident management an FCA-regulated activity?
- No. Recovering and managing the physical damage to a vehicle - arranging recovery, storage, an engineer's report, repairs and a replacement vehicle, and corresponding with the third-party insurer about those costs - is not 'regulated claims management activity' as defined by the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Regulated Activities) Order 2001 and the Claims Management Activity Order 2018. It therefore does not require FCA authorisation. Pursuing a personal-injury or financial claim for a fee does require FCA authorisation, which is why CityGrip refers those elements to authorised partners rather than handling them in-house.
- Do I need a claims management company after a non-fault accident?
- Not for the vehicle side. Recovery, storage, the engineer's report, repairs, a replacement vehicle and getting the at-fault insurer to pay are accident-management tasks an accident-management business handles directly. You only need an FCA-regulated CMC or an SRA-regulated solicitor if you are also pursuing a personal-injury claim or another regulated claim. CityGrip manages the accident itself and, where you are injured, refers the injury claim - with your explicit written consent - to an authorised CMC or solicitor.
- What does a claims management company actually do?
- An FCA-authorised CMC carries out 'regulated claims management activity': seeking out, referrals and identification of claims; advice, investigation or representation in relation to a claim; and, for some firms, handling personal-injury, financial-services, housing-disrepair or specified-benefit claims. They must comply with the FCA's Claims Management: Conduct of Business sourcebook (CMCOB), including pre-contract disclosure, a fee summary and a 14-day cancellation right. Their fee is usually a percentage of the compensation recovered, subject to FCA fee caps for certain claim types.
- How are accident management and CMC fees different?
- Genuine accident management on a non-fault claim is provided at no upfront cost to you: the recovery, storage, engineer, repair and replacement-vehicle charges are recovered from the at-fault driver's insurer under the law of damages, so you pay nothing if liability is admitted. A CMC's fee is a charge to you - typically a percentage of the personal-injury or financial compensation it recovers, disclosed up front under CMCOB and capped by the FCA for relevant claim types. The two are different commercial models because they sit on different sides of the regulated perimeter.
- Why does CityGrip refer injury claims instead of handling them?
- Because pursuing a personal-injury claim for a fee is a regulated activity. CityGrip is an accident-management business, not an FCA-authorised CMC or an SRA-regulated law firm, so it does not give legal advice or run injury claims itself. Where you have been injured, it refers the injury element - only with your explicit, recorded consent under UK GDPR Article 7 - to an authorised CMC or SRA-regulated solicitor who holds the right permissions. You are never obliged to use the partner, and the accident-management service does not depend on it.
- Is consent required before my details are passed to a solicitor or CMC?
- Yes. Sharing your personal data with a third-party injury firm is a separate processing purpose, so it requires a lawful basis. CityGrip relies on your freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous consent under UK GDPR Article 7 and the Data Protection Act 2018. You are told who the partner is, what is shared and why, you opt in deliberately, and you can withdraw consent at any time. No injury referral happens by default and the property-damage accident management proceeds regardless of whether you consent to an injury referral.
- Are accident management companies regulated at all?
- Accident management for property damage is not within the FCA's claims-management perimeter, but the business is still bound by general UK law: consumer-protection and unfair-terms rules, the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 cancellation rights, UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018 for your data, and the law of damages and mitigation that governs what the at-fault insurer must pay. If a credit-hire agreement is regulated under the Consumer Credit Act 1974, the relevant consumer-credit protections also apply. So 'unregulated by the FCA for claims management' is not the same as 'unregulated'.
Talk to a real person
Not sure which one you need?We handle it end-to-end.
Tell us about your collision. We will handle the accident management - recovery, storage, engineer, repairs and a like-for-like replacement vehicle - at no upfront cost, and explain clearly if and when a regulated injury referral makes sense. Across England, Scotland and Wales.
Calls may be recorded for quality and compliance. We do not provide legal advice. Personal injury enquiries are referred only with your consent to authorised partners.
Visit our team
London office
124 City Road
London, EC1V 2NX
Coverage
- Phone & accident form24 / 7
- Recovery dispatch24 / 7
- Repair coordinationMon-Sat 8:00 - 18:00
- SundaysEmergency only
45+UK cities
9vehicle types
GDPRcompliant
Tip: submit the accident form first - our team will call back with a reference and next steps.